I started my journey into manual lawn mowing three years ago when my gas mower finally died. What began as a temporary solution turned into a complete lifestyle change. Today, I’m reviewing all 14 top-rated reel mowers to help you make the switch to zero-emission lawn care.
Here’s what surprised me most: using a reel mower isn’t just about being eco-friendly. My lawn has never looked better, I’ve saved hundreds on gas and maintenance, and I actually enjoy the quiet morning mowing sessions. No more waking the neighbors at 7 AM or breathing exhaust fumes.
After testing these models and analyzing over 55,000 customer reviews, I found clear winners for different yard sizes and grass types. The Fiskars StaySharp leads with innovative blade technology that eliminates sharpening, while the American Lawn Mower Company’s model dominates sales with 2,000 units sold monthly.
We earn from qualifying purchases.
The numbers shocked me when I first researched lawn mower emissions. According to the EPA, one gas-powered lawn mower produces as much pollution in one hour as driving a car for 100 miles. That’s right – your weekly mowing session creates more emissions than your daily commute.
I calculated my own carbon footprint reduction after switching to a reel mower. Previously, my gas mower consumed about 20 gallons of fuel per season. That’s roughly 180 pounds of CO2 emissions eliminated annually, not counting the oil changes and air filter replacements. Multiply that by millions of households, and we’re talking about significant environmental impact.
The noise pollution aspect hit home when my neighbor thanked me for switching. Gas mowers typically operate at 95 decibels – that’s as loud as a motorcycle. Reel mowers? They produce a gentle scissors sound at about 55 decibels. I can mow while my kids nap, listen to birds singing, and actually have a conversation with passing neighbors.
Beyond emissions and noise, reel mowers provide a superior cut for grass health. The scissor-like action cleanly slices grass blades rather than tearing them like rotary mowers. This clean cut reduces water loss, prevents disease entry points, and keeps your lawn greener with less watering. It’s a win for both the environment and your water bill.
After testing 14 models, I’ve learned that cutting width makes the biggest difference in mowing time. The 20-inch Scotts model covers 40% more ground per pass than a 14-inch mower. For my 5,000 square foot lawn, that’s the difference between 30 and 45 minutes of mowing. However, wider isn’t always better – narrow mowers excel in tight spaces and around landscaping.
Blade count directly affects cut quality, especially with certain grass types. The Earthwise 7-blade model delivered the finest cut on my Bermuda grass test patch, while the 4-blade American Lawn Mower handled thick Kentucky bluegrass just fine. More blades mean cleaner cuts on fine grasses but require more pushing effort.
Weight matters more than you’d think. The 19-pound American Lawn Mower feels effortless on flat terrain, while the 51.7-pound Fiskars requires real muscle on slopes. That said, the Fiskars’ InertiaDrive system makes it easier to push than its weight suggests. I recommend staying under 30 pounds unless you have specific features you need.
Height adjustment range becomes critical if you maintain different grass types or seasonal heights. Most models offer 0.5 to 2.5 inches, but the Fiskars extends to 4 inches – perfect for letting grass grow taller during drought conditions. The GARDENA’s lower range (0.47-1.65 inches) suits those maintaining putting green-style lawns.
For those interested in essential gardening tools, a quality reel mower pairs perfectly with other manual garden equipment for a completely eco-friendly yard care system.
StaySharp blade technology - never needs sharpening
InertiaDrive Reel - 2x cutting power of standard reels
60% easier to push despite 51.7 lb weight
Reversible grass chute for flexible discharge
VersaCut technology handles all grass types
3-year limited warranty
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.2★ (2,992 reviews)
Price: $279.66 (was $308.69)
Cutting Width: 18 inches
Weight: 51.7 pounds
Height Range: 1-4 inches
Bought past month: 100
The Fiskars StaySharp completely changed my expectations for reel mowers. Despite weighing 51.7 pounds, it pushes easier than my old 30-pound model thanks to the InertiaDrive system. The blades slice through grass like butter – even the thick patches my other mowers struggled with.
What really sold me was the StaySharp blade technology. Three years later, it still cuts like new without any sharpening. Customer reviews consistently praise this feature, with many reporting 5+ years of maintenance-free operation. The reversible grass chute is brilliant for directing clippings away from flower beds.
What Customers Love: “Sounds like cutting paper” appears in dozens of reviews. Users rave about the quiet operation and professional-looking results. The VersaCut technology genuinely handles St. Augustine, Zoysia, and Bermuda grass equally well.
Common Concerns: The weight is real – several reviewers mention struggling on hills. The $280 price tag puts it firmly in premium territory, though most say it’s worth every penny for the quality and zero maintenance.
Bottom Line: Best overall reel mower if you can handle the weight and price. Perfect for medium to large lawns where the 18-inch width and superior cutting power justify the investment.
20-inch cutting width - largest in category
5-blade ball bearing reel for smooth operation
Dual tracking 10-inch wheels for stability
Quick-snap height adjusters - tool-free
Heat-treated alloy steel blades
Ball bearing design for longevity
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.1★ (2,875 reviews)
Price: $149.99
Cutting Width: 20 inches
Weight: 34 pounds
Height Range: 1-3 inches
Bought past month: 200
I tested the Scotts 20-inch on my friend’s half-acre lot, and the time savings were dramatic. Each pass covers 40% more ground than standard 14-inch models. We finished in 35 minutes what typically takes an hour with his old mower.
The dual tracking wheels make a noticeable difference in straight-line stability. Unlike single-wheel designs that wander, this tracks like it’s on rails. The quick-snap height adjusters actually work as advertised – no tools, no hassle, just snap to your desired height.
What Customers Love: “Game changer for larger lawns” is a common theme. Users appreciate the wide cut reducing mowing time and the smooth ball bearing operation that doesn’t bind up like cheaper models.
Common Concerns: Some users report handle durability issues after extended use. The 34-pound weight becomes noticeable on slopes, and thick weeds can stop the blades if you’re moving too slowly.
Bottom Line: Ideal for medium to large flat lawns where coverage speed matters most. The 20-inch width is unmatched at this price point.
Contact-free cutting technique - blades don't touch
German engineering with 10-year warranty
Non-stick coated cylinder prevents grass buildup
Folding handle for 50% storage space reduction
Compatible with optional grass catcher
Special tread wheels for better traction
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.2★ (1,474 reviews)
Price: $139.99
Cutting Width: 16 inches
Weight: 20 pounds
Height Range: 0.47-1.65 inches
Bought past month: 100
The GARDENA brings European precision to lawn care. At 20 pounds, it’s incredibly light yet feels solid. The contact-free cutting technology means the blades never touch the bed knife, reducing wear and maintaining sharpness longer than traditional designs.
I particularly appreciate the folding handle design. My garage is tight, and this mower takes up half the space of conventional models when stored. The non-stick coating actually works – wet grass that would clog other mowers slides right off.
What Customers Love: European quality shows in every detail. Users mention the precision engineering, smooth operation, and how it maintains edge sharpness after years of use. The 10-year warranty provides serious peace of mind.
Common Concerns: The 1.65-inch maximum height is too low for some grass types. A few users wished for a wider cutting height range, especially for seasonal adjustments.
Bottom Line: Perfect for those who value quality engineering and have smaller, well-maintained lawns. The lightweight design makes it ideal for users who prioritize easy maneuverability.
7-blade system - most in category for finest cut
Ball bearing reel for smooth operation
Self-cutting blade design maintains sharpness
Durable steel side plates for longevity
Planet-friendly zero emissions operation
Ideal for warm-season grasses
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.2★ (1,672 reviews)
Price: $129.99 (when available)
Cutting Width: 16 inches
Weight: 21.8 pounds
Height Range: 0.5-2.5 inches
Bought past month: 400 (when in stock)
The Earthwise 7-blade delivers the finest cut I’ve seen from a manual mower. On my test patch of Bermuda grass, it created a carpet-like finish that rivals golf course quality. The extra blades make a real difference on fine-textured grasses.
Each blade pass overlaps more with seven blades, resulting in cleaner cuts even at faster walking speeds. The ball bearing design keeps everything smooth despite the additional blade resistance. It’s noticeably better than 5-blade models on warm-season grasses.
What Customers Love: Bermuda grass owners consistently rate this as their top choice. The cut quality rivals powered reel mowers costing thousands more. Many mention it handles St. Augustine and Zoysia beautifully too.
Common Concerns: Availability is the biggest issue – it’s frequently out of stock. The seven blades require more effort to push, especially in thick grass. Some found assembly instructions unclear.
Bottom Line: The ultimate choice for warm-season grass perfectionists. When available, it offers unmatched cut quality for fine-textured lawns.
Includes 7-gallon removable grass collection bag
14-inch cutting width for small yards
5-blade cutting system
Adjustable cutting heights
Complete package under $120
Cordless manual operation
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.2★ (54 reviews)
Price: $119.99
Cutting Width: 14 inches
Weight: 25 pounds (estimated)
Grass Catcher: 7 gallons
Bought past month: 50+
Finding a reel mower with a grass catcher under $120 seemed impossible until I discovered the Goplus. The 7-gallon bag holds enough clippings for my entire front yard without emptying. This feature alone makes it worth considering for neat freaks like me.
The bag attachment doesn’t interfere with mowing action, and removal for emptying takes seconds. For composting enthusiasts, this setup makes grass collection effortless. The adjustable heights work well for seasonal changes.
What Customers Love: The included grass catcher is the star feature. Users love getting a complete package without buying accessories separately. Many mention it’s perfect for small, manicured yards.
Common Concerns: As a newer brand, long-term durability remains unproven. The 14-inch width means more passes on larger lawns. Some question build quality compared to established brands.
Bottom Line: Best value for those wanting grass collection capability. Ideal for small yards where the narrow width isn’t a drawback.
18-inch cutting width for good coverage
5-blade ball bearing reel system
Unbreakable steel side plates
10-inch ball bearing wheels with radial tread
Cushioned loop handle for comfort
No tools required for assembly
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.2★ (9,038 reviews)
Price: $116.00
Cutting Width: 18 inches
Weight: 27 pounds
Height Range: 0.5-2.75 inches
Bought past month: 300
With over 9,000 reviews, the Great States 18-inch has proven itself through sheer volume. I understand why – it hits the sweet spot of width, weight, and price. At 27 pounds with an 18-inch cut, it’s manageable for most users while covering ground efficiently.
The ball bearing wheels with radial tread grip well on slopes and damp grass. Assembly genuinely requires no tools – everything clicks or slides into place. The cushioned loop handle reduces hand fatigue during longer mowing sessions.
What Customers Love: “Best bang for your buck” appears repeatedly in reviews. Users appreciate the American manufacturing, proven reliability, and that replacement parts are readily available. Many report using theirs for 5+ years.
Common Concerns: The handle engineering gets criticism for feeling flimsy. Some users struggle with initial assembly despite the “no tools” claim. Very tall grass can bog it down.
Bottom Line: The safe, proven choice for medium-sized lawns. Excellent value with a track record that speaks for itself.
Large 7.9-gallon grass collection bag
Sponge grip handle for maximum comfort
4-position height adjustment system
16-inch steel construction
Currently 10% off at $99.99
Removable grass catcher design
Key Specifications:
Rating: 3.4★ (87 reviews)
Price: $99.99 (was $110.99)
Cutting Width: 16 inches
Weight: 28 pounds (estimated)
Grass Catcher: 7.9 gallons
Bought past month: 100
The Walensee caught my attention with its 7.9-gallon grass catcher – the largest I’ve tested. For those who hate leaving clippings, this capacity means fewer trips to the compost bin. The sponge grip handle is surprisingly comfortable during extended use.
The 4-position height adjustment offers more flexibility than many pricier models. However, the 3.4-star rating suggests quality control issues. Some users report excellent performance while others encountered problems, indicating inconsistent manufacturing.
What Customers Love: The massive grass catcher and comfortable grip get consistent praise. Users appreciate the height adjustment options and current discount pricing.
Common Concerns: Quality consistency is the main issue. Some units arrive with defects or develop problems quickly. The newer brand lacks the track record of established manufacturers.
Bottom Line: Worth considering if grass collection is your priority and you’re willing to risk the mixed reviews for the features and price.
18-inch width at budget price point
Includes grass catcher bag
Additional $8 coupon available
1.37-2.44 inch height range
5-blade manual system
20% discount from $116.99
Key Specifications:
Rating: 3.8★ (66 reviews)
Price: $93.59 (was $116.99)
Cutting Width: 18 inches
Weight: 30 pounds (estimated)
Coupon: Save $8.00
Bought past month: 50
Finding an 18-inch mower with grass catcher under $100 (with coupon) seemed impossible. The VEVOR delivers surprising value. Yes, it’s basic, but it covers ground quickly and collects clippings – exactly what budget-conscious buyers need.
The cutting performance matches pricier 18-inch models in normal conditions. Where it falls short is build quality – everything feels a bit lighter and less refined. For occasional use or smaller budgets, these compromises might be acceptable.
What Customers Love: The 18-inch width at this price point is unbeatable. Including a grass catcher adds significant value. The extra coupon makes it even more attractive.
Common Concerns: Build quality matches the price – don’t expect premium materials. Assembly instructions are minimal. Some report durability issues after a season.
Bottom Line: Best ultra-budget option for those needing 18-inch coverage. Perfect for renters or temporary solutions.
#2 bestseller rank in category
Lightest at only 19 pounds
Over 22,000 reviews
125+ years American manufacturing
4-blade cutting system
2000 units sold monthly
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.2★ (22,481 reviews)
Price: $89.99
Cutting Width: 14 inches
Weight: 19 pounds
Height Range: 0.5-1.75 inches
Bought past month: 2,000
With 22,481 reviews and 2,000 monthly sales, this mower has earned its reputation through sheer numbers. At 19 pounds, it’s the lightest option I tested – my 13-year-old nephew uses it without any struggle. Sometimes simple is best.
The 4-blade system might seem inferior, but it works perfectly for regular maintenance mowing. The American Lawn Mower Company has made reel mowers since 1895, and that experience shows in the thoughtful design and reliability.
What Customers Love: The overwhelming review count tells the story – this mower just works. Users love the featherweight design, trouble-free operation, and that it’s genuinely made in America. Many report 10+ years of service.
Common Concerns: Four blades mean less overlap and potentially missed spots if you rush. The narrow width requires patience on larger lawns. Limited height range doesn’t suit all grass types.
Bottom Line: The safe, proven choice for small yards. When 22,000+ people rate something 4.2 stars, it’s doing something right.
Classic hand reel design
Traditional push operation
Simple reliable mechanism
Great States quality
American-made heritage
Durable steel construction
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.2★ (9,038 reviews)
Price: $89.99
Cutting Width: 14 inches
Weight: 20 pounds (estimated)
Design: Traditional hand reel
Bought past month: 200
Sometimes old-school is the right school. This traditional hand reel design hasn’t changed much in decades because it doesn’t need to. No fancy features, just solid construction and reliable cutting for those who appreciate simplicity.
The hand reel mechanism requires more effort but offers better control in tight spots. I found it perfect for precision work around garden beds where modern designs feel clumsy. It’s lawn mowing stripped to its essence.
What Customers Love: Traditionalists appreciate the classic design and bombproof reliability. Many inherited similar models from parents and wanted the same dependability. The simple mechanism rarely fails.
Common Concerns: The traditional design requires more physical effort. No modern conveniences like improved bearings or ergonomic handles. Limited to basic cutting without refinements.
Bottom Line: Perfect for purists who want traditional, reliable lawn care without modern complexity.
18-inch width under $90
5-blade cutting system
21% discount from list price
300 monthly sales volume
Energy-free operation
Budget-friendly wide cut
Key Specifications:
Rating: 3.7★ (512 reviews)
Price: $89.00 (was $112.39)
Cutting Width: 18 inches
Weight: 25 pounds (estimated)
Blade Count: 5-blade
Bought past month: 300
The LawnMaster proves you don’t need to spend big for wide coverage. At $89 for an 18-inch cut, it undercuts similar models by $30-40. The 300 monthly sales suggest many buyers agree with this value proposition.
Performance matches the price – adequate but not exceptional. It cuts grass effectively in normal conditions but struggles with challenging situations that premium models handle easily. For occasional use or tight budgets, it does the job.
What Customers Love: The 18-inch width at this price point is the main draw. Users appreciate getting wide coverage without premium pricing. The current discount makes it even more attractive.
Common Concerns: The 3.7 rating reflects quality compromises. Some report durability issues after one season. Build quality doesn’t match established brands.
Bottom Line: Best for budget buyers who prioritize cutting width over build quality and features.
Limited time deal at $83.68
700 units sold last month
16-inch optimal size
5-blade system
12% discount active
High sales volume leader
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.1★ (894 reviews)
Price: $83.68 (was $94.81)
Cutting Width: 16 inches
Weight: 23 pounds (estimated)
Limited Time Deal: Yes
Bought past month: 700
With 700 units sold last month, this LawnMaster is clearly hitting a sweet spot. The 16-inch width balances coverage and maneuverability perfectly. At $83.68 with the limited time deal, it’s hard to find better value.
The 4.1 rating with nearly 900 reviews suggests consistent satisfaction. It lacks premium features but delivers solid basic performance. For many users, that’s exactly what they need without overpaying.
What Customers Love: The combination of fair pricing, good width, and decent quality resonates with buyers. Many mention it exceeds expectations for a budget model. The high sales volume indicates strong word-of-mouth.
Common Concerns: Deal pricing creates urgency but may not last. Some worry about long-term durability with the budget construction. Limited warranty compared to premium brands.
Bottom Line: Jump on this deal if you need a 16-inch mower now. The sales volume and ratings suggest it’s a solid choice at this price.
Smallest 12-inch cutting width
Lowest price at $44.99
Includes grass catcher bag
Perfect 5.0 rating (5 reviews)
Adjustable cutting height
Ultra-portable design
Key Specifications:
Rating: 5.0★ (5 reviews)
Price: $44.99
Cutting Width: 12 inches
Weight: 18 pounds (estimated)
Features: Grass catcher included
Bought past month: Minimal
At $44.99, this 12-inch model costs less than a tank of gas for most riding mowers. The ultra-compact size fits where nothing else will – I tested it in a tiny courtyard garden where even a 14-inch mower was awkward.
The included grass catcher at this price surprised me. While the 12-inch width means many more passes, it’s perfect for postage-stamp yards or detail work around landscaping. Think of it as a precision tool, not a lawn coverage machine.
What Customers Love: The five reviewers gave perfect scores, praising the compact size and unbeatable price. The grass catcher inclusion at $45 is remarkable value.
Common Concerns: Only five reviews means limited reliability data. The 12-inch width is impractical for anything beyond tiny spaces. Generic branding offers no support network.
Bottom Line: Only suitable for the smallest yards or as a detail trimmer. The price is attractive but the limitations are real.
17-inch StaySharp technology
Never needs blade sharpening
Premium build quality
Eco-friendly cordless operation
13% discount available
Fiskars lifetime warranty
Key Specifications:
Rating: 4.2★ (2,992 reviews)
Price: $214.83 (was $247.99)
Cutting Width: 17 inches
Weight: 45 pounds (estimated)
Technology: StaySharp system
Bought past month: 50
The 17-inch Fiskars splits the difference between the 16 and 18-inch models, and for many yards, it’s the Goldilocks choice. You get StaySharp technology in a slightly more manageable package than the 18-inch version.
After using both Fiskars models, the 17-inch feels better balanced for medium yards. The weight reduction from the 18-inch model is noticeable on slopes, while still covering ground efficiently. The StaySharp technology remains the star feature.
What Customers Love: Users appreciate getting Fiskars quality at a lower price than the 18-inch model. The 17-inch width suits most suburban yards perfectly. StaySharp technology eliminates maintenance headaches forever.
Common Concerns: Still expensive compared to conventional mowers. The 45-pound weight requires physical capability. Some question paying premium prices for manual equipment.
Bottom Line: The smart premium choice for medium yards where the 18-inch model is overkill but quality matters.
After three years of reel mower ownership, I’ve learned that minimal maintenance yields maximum performance. Unlike gas mowers, there’s no oil to change, spark plugs to replace, or air filters to clean. Most reel mowers need blade adjustment once per season and sharpening every 3-5 years.
Storage makes a huge difference in longevity. I keep mine in the garage, elevated off the concrete floor to prevent moisture damage. A quick spray with WD-40 on the blades before winter storage prevents rust. Some users cover theirs, but I find good ventilation more important than covering.
For those setting up complete sustainable outdoor furniture and lawn care systems, proper equipment storage becomes part of your eco-friendly outdoor design.
Most reel mowers work best on grass under 4 inches tall. I learned this the hard way after vacation – anything over 5 inches requires multiple passes or cutting in stages. The Fiskars models handle taller grass better than others, but even they have limits.
Standard blades need sharpening every 3-5 years with regular use. The Fiskars StaySharp models never need sharpening – I’ve confirmed this after three years of use. Signs you need sharpening include grass tearing instead of cutting cleanly and increased pushing effort.
Give yourself 2-3 mowing sessions to adjust. The key is maintaining steady walking speed – too slow and the blades don’t spin properly. I tell newcomers to walk like they’re late for something but not running.
They work on most grass types but excel with certain varieties. Bermuda, Zoysia, and Kentucky bluegrass cut beautifully. St. Augustine and thick fescue can be challenging. The more blades (5-7), the better the cut on difficult grasses.
I calculated my savings at $200 annually – no gas ($120), no oil ($20), no maintenance ($60). Over 10 years, that’s $2,000 plus the health benefits of exercise and the environmental impact of zero emissions.
Switching to a reel mower transformed my relationship with lawn care. What started as an eco-friendly choice became something I genuinely enjoy. The quiet morning mowing sessions, the exercise, the perfect scissor-cut stripes – it all adds up to a better experience than I ever had with gas mowers.
For most users, I recommend starting with the Great States 18-inch for good value or investing in the Fiskars StaySharp for zero maintenance. Small yard owners should consider the American Lawn Mower 14-inch bestseller. The key is matching the mower to your specific needs rather than buying based on features you won’t use.
The environmental impact can’t be overstated. If even 10% of American households switched to reel mowers, we’d eliminate millions of tons of CO2 emissions annually. Add in the health benefits, cost savings, and superior cut quality, and the choice becomes clear. Your lawn, wallet, and planet will thank you.
As you design your complete eco-friendly outdoor space, consider pairing your new reel mower with non-toxic outdoor rugs for a fully sustainable backyard environment. The future of lawn care is quiet, clean, and surprisingly satisfying.
Don't let aphids, slugs, and caterpillars ruin another plant. Take back control with simple, natural methods that actually work.
